A boots dilemma.

So, my ankle boot collection overfloweth. I could use a pair of knee-high boots. I had a black leather vintage pair last year, but having worn them all over France and subsequently bruised the balls of my feet, I decided it's probably best not to wear them again. Here are my options:


Fornarina Nico boot, $299. piperlime.com
I'd prefer suede if I'm going to splurge on a knee-high pair, but these look identical to the aforementioned vintage pair. They're just beautiful.


Slouchy Suede Foldover Boot, $88. urbanoutfitters.com
Perfect: affordable, suede, not too much heel, comes in black or brown. I'm leaning toward black, for versatility's sake.


Carlos Santana Hot Rod, $189. piperlime.com
Brown, not black, but just kinda cool. I think I like the chunky heel.

Thoughts?